Every so often another researcher that I'm sharing information with asks (or I ask them), Do you have a direct link between this father and this daughter? or, Okay, but where's the proof? When I have to tell them no, I have no direct proof of a person's parentage, or maiden name, or whatever, I feel I've disappointed them greatly (or they've disappointed me... I don't know which feels worse, really.)
In the immortal words of Bill Clinton, I feel their pain. I, too, long for that elusive birth certificate marked so clearly "30 March 1774, a boy, named Charles for his well-loved paternal Uncle, was born to parents John McLaughlin and Mary McLaughlin, nee Smith, of County Itllneverhappen"
In much of pre-1850 America, give or take a decade or two, "proof" documents, containing concrete direct evidence from primary sources, are all too often hard to come by. So while I still hope for that document, I have to accept the fact, gracefully and with good humor, that I probably will never find it. Instead I have set my cap for well-researched, carefully formed "Proof Arguments". These can be prepared to explain why you believe a certain questionable document qualifies as proof, when you are torn between two conflicting documents, or for presenting an argument as to why you believe a situation to be fact, though you have no direct proof.
Every so often I'll post one of the Proof Arguments here that I've worked on, though they are always a work-in-progress. The format I've used has proven the most useful to me, though it certainly can be changed to include anything a researcher thinks is necessary or helpful to their argument.
Here's the first:
PROOF ARGUMENT
Hugh McLaughlin, Revolutionary War Soldier1 of Augusta County, Virginia2, husband of Agnes Gwin3, (Soldier) is apprenticed fourteen-year-old son of Hugh McLaughlin, Augusta County, Virginia, 17724 (Apprentice)
By Joan M. Kay
Exhaustive search of records has shown no other candidate. Considered: Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. Quality of evidence: +6
The year of birth for each Hugh closely matches. Considered: Apprentice was born approximately 1757. Soldier enlisted in 1777, which would place him at 19 to 20 years old, an expected, reasonable age. Also considered: Perhaps he was an older enlistee? Result: Soldier married Agnes “Nancy” Gwin in 1789, which would then place Apprentice at 32. Chances are not great that a man much older than 32 would marry a 19-year-old woman, though not out of the question. Also considered: Soldier died in 1798
5; Apprentice would then be 42, a relatively early death. Quality of evidence: +5
Apprentice was bound out to become a currier (curing/dressing skins). Soldier had in his inventory at his death “tools for dressing skins.” Considered: These could be common tools of the day. Result: A check of the inventories for Bath County for 50 years from 1791 showed only one other set of currier’s tools
6. Quality of evidence: +8
Apprentice had a brother named James. Soldier lived close to James McLaughlin in Bath County according to Personal Property Tax Books
7 (they were regularly taxed on the same day, indicating close proximity). Considered: James was a common name. Quality of evidence: +4
I have no negative evidence.
Records examined:
Census Records; Virginia Counties. National Archives, Washington, DC.
Court Records; Augusta County, Virginia. Library of Virginia, Richmond.
Court Records; Bath County, Virginia. Library of Virginia, Richmond.
Land Records, including grants, deed books, and taxes; Virginia Counties. Library of Virginia, Richmond.
Personal Property Tax Records; Virginia Counties. Library of Virginia, Richmond.
Revolutionary War Records, including indexes of soldiers, service records, pension and bounty land warrant applications. National Archives, Washington, DC.
Voting Records; Bath County, Virginia. Ordered from and viewed at (LDS) Family History Center, Lexington Park, Maryland.
My Conclusion:
Hugh McLaughlin is both Apprentice and Soldier.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Footnotes:
1"Compiled Service Records of Soldiers Who Served in the American Army During the Revolutionary War" National Archives Publication. Entry for Hugh McGlaughlin. Microfilm Publication: M881 roll 69, Gist's Regiment. Repository: National Archives, Washington, DC.
2"Revolutionary War Pension and Bounty Land Warrant Application Files, 1800 to 1900" National Archives Publication. Entry for the soldier Hugh McGlaughlin. Microfilm Publication: M804 roll 1684. Repository: National Archives, Washington, DC.
3Ibid
4Augusta County, Virginia. Order Book XIV, p 329. (17 Mar 1772, at issue, Hugh McLaughlin, orphan.) Repository: Library of Virginia, Richmond.
5Bath County, Virginia. Wills Book 1, p 125-126. (15 Oct 1798, at issue, Hugh McGloughlin Estate Appraisal). Repository: Bath County, Virginia, Courthouse; Warm Springs, VA.
6Bruns, Jean Randolph.
Abstracts of the Wills and Inventories of Bath County,Virginia, 1791-1842, (Baltimore, Clearfield Company, 1995) Repository: Joan M. Kay, Huntingtown, MD
7Auditor of Public Accounts., "Personal Property Tax Books Bath County [VA], 1791-1816." Repository: Library of Virginia, Richmond. Microfilm Publication: Reel 31.
Dedicated to preserving the history of the McLaughlin family, wherever they may be! Historical documents, photos, family histories, and more. To add your family history to the site, email here. Please SEARCH this site from the search bar above left or BROWSE topics listed in sidebar.
God's Mountain, McLaughlin's Valley 
